top of page
In Teh Chang Khoon v Tasek Corporation, the Court of Appeal awarded RM301,750 to a manager constructively dismissed after cancer leave. Lessons for HR
Case Summary

Constructive Dismissal after Cancer Leave: Court of Appeal Orders RM301,750 in Tasek Corporation Case

Posted on November 16, 2026 by Karmen Fung

“A Court of Appeal reminder that return-to-work handling is a legal risk, not just an HR task.”

The Court of Appeal overturned the Industrial Court and High Court and found that a cement manufacturer constructively dismissed a manager who tried to return to work after treatment for blood cancer. The company was ordered to pay RM301,750. The case is a reminder that how an employer handles a return from medical leave can itself amount to dismissal. 

What is constructive dismissal?


It happens when the employer’s conduct is so serious a breach of the employment contract that the employee is entitled to treat himself as dismissed, even though no termination letter was issued. The test is whether the employer breached a fundamental term of the contract or showed it no longer intends to be bound by it (Wong Chee Hong v Cathay Organisation (M) Sdn Bhd [1988] 1 MLJ 92). Unreasonable conduct alone is not enough, and the employee carries the burden of proving he was dismissed.

What happened


Teh Chang Khoon joined Tasek Corporation Bhd as its security and employee welfare manager in March 2009. In January 2021 he was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma and underwent treatment until July that year, during which he was on paid medical leave.


According to the Court of Appeal, Teh repeatedly asked the company about returning to work after his medical leave, and the company did not respond. When he tried to return on 1 April 2022, he was refused entry to the factory. The company’s chief financial officer told him to resign or face disciplinary charges, and he was then escorted off the premises.


Teh’s claim for unfair dismissal was dismissed by the Industrial Court, and the High Court upheld that decision. He appealed to the Court of Appeal.

What the Court of Appeal decided


On 28 October 2026, the Court of Appeal unanimously allowed the appeal, with a three-member bench chaired by Justice Alwi Abdul Wahab. Justice Shahnaz Sulaiman delivered the ruling, with Justice Dean Wayne Daly as the third member. The court held that the company’s conduct amounted to constructive dismissal and ordered it to pay RM301,750, made up of RM169,920 in back wages, RM106,200 as compensation in lieu of reinstatement and RM25,630 in employer’s EPF contributions.

Why the Court found constructive dismissal


  1. Failure to respond to return-to-work enquiries. The court noted that the company did not answer Teh’s repeated questions about resuming work after his medical leave.

  2. The employee handbook was overlooked. The Industrial Court and High Court erred by not considering the company’s own obligation under its employee handbook to arrange a medical re-examination to determine whether Teh was fit to resume work. The handbook requires the company’s medical officer to certify an employee’s fitness to work, and the company had previously sent other employees for such re-examinations.

  3. The “resign or face charges” ultimatum. Refusing Teh entry, telling him to resign or face disciplinary charges, and escorting him off the premises were part of the conduct the court took into account.

  4. No disciplinary action during medical leave. The court noted that the company had not started any disciplinary action against Teh during his paid medical leave over an alleged overpayment to a contractor. As we read it, the point is timing: the threat of charges surfaced only when he tried to return to work.

What employers should do

  • Respond to return-to-work enquiries promptly and in writing. Silence towards an employee on medical leave can be treated as part of a pattern of conduct, not a neutral omission.

  • Follow your own handbook. If your handbook says the company doctor must certify fitness before an employee returns, follow it. Not applying your own policy can be held against you, especially if you have applied it to other employees before.

  • Arrange the medical re-examination first. Where fitness to work is in doubt, the correct step is a documented medical assessment, not barring the employee from the premises. If the doctor finds the employee is not yet fit, discuss the options with them in writing, such as extended leave, a phased return or lighter duties. Termination on medical grounds should be a last resort, based on proper medical evidence and after consulting the employee.

  • Do not use ultimatums to force resignations. Telling an employee to resign or face charges is high-risk, particularly when no disciplinary process was started earlier. An employee who resigns under that kind of pressure can argue the resignation was not voluntary.

  • Keep misconduct and medical issues on separate tracks. Allegations that surface only when an employee tries to return will be examined for timing and motive. Genuine concerns should go through a proper, documented disciplinary process (investigation, show-cause letter and, where warranted, a domestic inquiry).

  • Document everything. Keep records made at the time: letters and emails to the employee, medical certificates, and who decided what and when. These are what the Industrial Court will look at if the matter is challenged.

E2’s view

The Court of Appeal’s decision in Teh Chang Khoon v Tasek Corporation Bhd shows that an employer can be found to have dismissed an employee without ever issuing a termination letter. In our view, the company lost on process. Its handbook already set out a fitness-to-work procedure, which it had used for other employees, but it did not use it for Teh. Instead, it ignored his enquiries and pressed him to resign under threat of charges. That was enough for the court to find constructive dismissal, even though the Industrial Court and High Court had reached the opposite conclusion.


For employers, the lesson is to manage an employee’s return from medical leave through a clear, documented process, not through informal pressure. Respond promptly, follow your own policies, rely on a proper medical assessment to decide fitness for work, and run any genuine misconduct allegation through a fair disciplinary process. Employees recovering from serious illness are among the most vulnerable members of the workforce, and the courts will look closely at how they are treated when they try to come back.


Organisations that have not reviewed their medical leave, fitness-to-work and return-to-work procedures recently should do so now, before a dispute puts them to the test. E2 would be happy to assist with a review, or with a live case you are managing.


Note: This summary is based on media reports of the Court of Appeal’s decision delivered on 28 October 2026, not on the written grounds of judgment. It is also open to the company to seek leave to appeal to the Federal Court. We will share an update once the grounds are available.


News source: https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/10/28/company-loses-appeal-over-dismissal-of-cancer-stricken-manager

Ask Our HR Consultants

Share Your ThoughtsBe the first to write a comment.

Upcoming Events

Stay ahead with our latest HR and IR programs designed to turn insights into action. Explore upcoming sessions featuring real case analyses, expert‑led discussions, and practical strategies to strengthen workplace compliance and leadership.

MC or Misuse? Understanding and Managing Sick Leave
bottom of page